(631) 704-1252 davonrea21@gmail.com Prince & Associates Realty Grp
Traffic Dashboard
Home
  • Home
  • Search
    • All Homes
    • Featured Listings
  • Communities
  • Buying
    • Buying Process
    • Mortgage Calculator
  • Selling
    • Selling Process
    • Home Valuation
    • Recently Sold
  • About
    • About Davon
    • Testimonials
    • Blog
  • Contact
Traffic Dashboard
Davon K Harris
(631) 704-1252 davonrea21@gmail.com
  • 1363 Fifth Avenue
    Bay Shore, NY 11706
Explore
  • Property Search
  • Communities
  • Buying
  • Selling
About
  • About
  • Contact Us
  • Testimonials
  • Blog
Local Guide
  • Search by City
  • Search by Subdivision
  • Search by Zip
  • Search by Area
Legal
  • Privacy
  • Terms
  • DMCA
  • Accessibility
  • Fair Housing
Account
  • Dashboard
  • Logout
  • Login
Realest Agent Day - Footer Logo
©2026 Prince & Associates Realty Grp. All rights reserved.
Website built by CloseHack.
OneKey MLS

IDX information is provided exclusively for personal, non-commercial use, and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed.

Back

Listings in Shelter Island Heights, NY

Realest Agent Day Prince & Associates Realty Grp

Get more information about Shelter Island Heights

Shelter Island Heights Listings Market Stats Subdivisions Zip Codes Neighborhood FAQs Nearby

Houses in Shelter Island Heights, NY

homeMore houses
13 Spring Garden Avenue
$2,995,000
KEY1047801
For Sale
13 Spring Garden Avenue Shelter Island Heights, NY 11965
3 Beds bathtub 2.5 Baths straighten 2300 sq ft
4 Bayview Avenue
$1,999,999
KEY1045616
For Sale
4 Bayview Avenue Shelter Island Heights, NY 11965
6 Beds bathtub 5.5 Baths straighten 6098 sq ft
11 Prospect Avenue
$2,595,000
KEY1022345
For Sale
11 Prospect Avenue Shelter Island Heights, NY 11965
4 Beds bathtub 2.5 Baths straighten 1994 sq ft

MARKET SNAPSHOT

The Market at a Glance

How homes have been selling here over the last 90 days.

home_work New This Week 0
Went Under Contract 0
trending_down Price Reductions 0
payments Median Sale Price $2,525,000 —
square_foot Price per Sq Ft —
schedule Avg Days on Market 199
sell Homes Sold 1
percent Sale-to-List Ratio 86.0%
inventory_2 Months of Inventory 5.9

Price & Sales History

Market data reflects closed sales over the last 90 days and is provided for informational purposes.

Realest Agent Day Prince & Associates Realty Grp (631) 704-1252 davonrea21@gmail.com

Zip Codes

BROWSE BY ZIP

Browse listings by postal code in this area.

000002 homes for saleMedian sale$85KPer sq ft$211 sale in the last 90 days
068071 home for saleMedian sale$1.2MPer sq ft$57218 sales in the last 90 days
068112 homes for saleMedian sale$500KPer sq ft$280106 sales in the last 90 days
068124 homes for saleMedian sale$550KPer sq ft$301110 sales in the last 90 days
068302 homes for saleMedian sale$725KPer sq ft$52539 sales in the last 90 days
068312 homes for saleMedian sale$2.5MPer sq ft$65028 sales in the last 90 days
068704 homes for saleMedian sale$3.9MPer sq ft$1,23950 sales in the last 90 days
069031 home for saleMedian sale$1.3MPer sq ft$37256 sales in the last 90 days
076011 home for saleMedian sale$315KPer sq ft$791 sales in the last 90 days
076771 home for saleMedian sale$1.4MPer sq ft$2121 sales in the last 90 days
078271 home for saleMedian sale$350KPer sq ft$2115 sales in the last 90 days
088161 home for saleMedian sale$685KPer sq ft$284178 sales in the last 90 days
View All Zip Codes
Get Alerts Advanced Search
  • Grid
  • Map
  • List
13 Spring Garden Avenue For Sale
$2,995,000
13 Spring Garden AvenueShelter Island Heights, NY 11965
  • 3 bd
  • 2.5 ba
  • 2300 sqft
  • Built 1875
  • KEY1047801
4 Bayview Avenue For Sale
$1,999,999
4 Bayview AvenueShelter Island Heights, NY 11965
  • 6 bd
  • 5.5 ba
  • 6098 sqft
  • Built 2001
  • KEY1045616
11 Prospect Avenue For Sale
$2,595,000
11 Prospect AvenueShelter Island Heights, NY 11965
  • 4 bd
  • 2.5 ba
  • 1994 sqft
  • Built 1890
  • KEY1022345
3
Nearby Cities
All Cities
  • Shelter Island1.2 mi24 Listings
  • Greenport1.6 mi47 Listings
  • East Marion3 mi22 Listings
  • Southold4.2 mi77 Listings
  • Orient5.3 mi16 Listings
  • Sag Harbor6.5 mi32 Listings
  • Peconic6.5 mi12 Listings
  • Cutchogue8.1 mi52 Listings
  • New Suffolk8.9 mi3 Listings
  • East Hampton11 mi78 Listings
  • Mattituck11 mi47 Listings
  • Bridgehampton10 mi11 Listings
Similar Searches
  • For Sale in Shelter Island Heights
  • Rentals in Shelter Island Heights
  • Houses in Shelter Island Heights
  • Condos & Apartments in Shelter Island Heights
  • Townhouses & Duplexes in Shelter Island Heights
  • Lots & Land in Shelter Island Heights
  • Farms & Ranches in Shelter Island Heights
Featured Areas
All Areas
  • Suffolk County6745 Listings
  • New York City5391 Listings
  • Nassau County4806 Listings
Featured Searches
Advanced Search
  • $200k to $300k Homes
  • $300k to $400k Homes
  • $400k to $500k Homes
  • Acreage
  • Commercial Properties
  • Farms & Ranches
  • Golf Course Homes
  • Homes Listed this Week
  • Homes with 2+ Beds
  • Homes with Pools
  • Large Houses (2k+ sqft)
  • Luxury Condos ($400k+)
  • Multi-Family Homes
  • New Construction
  • Oceanfront Condos
  • Rentals Under $2k
  • Rentals with Pets
  • Under $200k Homes
  • Under $250k Homes
  • Water View Homes
  • Water View Homes
Popular Cities
All Cities
  • Flushing788 Listings
  • Bronx674 Listings
  • Brooklyn517 Listings
  • Poughkeepsie309 Listings
  • Middletown284 Listings
  • Monroe276 Listings
  • Jamaica267 Listings
  • Newburgh267 Listings
  • Yonkers254 Listings
  • Massapequa198 Listings
Popular Subdivisions
All Subdivisions
  • Heritage4 Listings
  • The Colony3 Listings
  • Homestead Village3 Listings
  • Riverwalk2 Listings
  • Fairways2 Listings
  • Harvest Ridge2 Listings
  • The Hollows1 Listings
  • Seasons1 Listings
  • Woodland Estates1 Listings
Popular Zip Codes
All Zips
  • Homes in 331601 Listings
  • Homes in 342861 Listings
  • Homes in 088311 Listings
  • Homes in 342911 Listings
  • Homes in 11354420 Listings
  • Homes in 212231 Listings
  • Homes in 10950290 Listings
  • Homes in 12550270 Listings
  • Homes in 076011 Listings
  • Homes in 11746250 Listings

City Guide

About Shelter Island Heights

Real Estate & Housing

Neighborhoods

Lifestyle in Shelter Island Heights

Schools & Education

Getting Around

Parks & Recreation

About Shelter Island Heights

Frequently asked questions

Where do we start?

Start with mortgage pre-approval — it tells you what you can spend before you fall in love with a home. From there, we'll help you find neighborhoods that fit how you actually live, and walk you through every step of the purchase.

How long does it take to sell?

Timelines depend on the market, your price, and your home's condition. Right now, most well-priced homes sell in 30 to 60 days. We'll put together a plan that makes your property stand out and gets it in front of serious buyers.

What costs should I anticipate?

Buyers usually pay closing costs — lender fees, title insurance, inspections — roughly 2 to 5 percent of the purchase price. Sellers handle agent commissions and any repairs you agree to. We walk through every cost up front, so there are no surprises at closing.

Should I buy or sell first?

It depends on your finances and what the market looks like. Bridge loans and contingent offers each work in different situations. We'll talk through the trade-offs so you can move forward with a plan that makes sense for you.

Why work with us?

We know these neighborhoods because we live here. Every agent on our team works in the community they serve, so the advice you get goes deeper than what a spreadsheet can tell you. We use technology to keep things clear and simple. The result? A smooth experience from your first search to the day you get the keys.

Still have questions about Shelter Island Heights?

Get in touch
  • Local Guide
  • Cities

Explore the area

Nearby cities

Bridgehampton, NY11 homes for saleMedian$3,900,000Days on market15
Cutchogue, NY52 homes for saleMedian$1,285,000Days on market60Per sq ft$170
East Hampton, NY78 homes for saleMedian$1,850,000−1.1%Days on market151Per sq ft$378
East Marion, NY22 homes for saleMedian$1,276,500Days on market92Per sq ft$476
Greenport, NY47 homes for saleMedian$999,000Days on market108Per sq ft$295
Hampton Bays, NY112 homes for saleMedian$1,057,500+23.0%Days on market108Per sq ft$617
Jamesport, NY18 homes for saleMedian$994,500Days on market83Per sq ft$406
Laurel, NY12 homes for saleMedian$1,275,000Days on market110Per sq ft$222
Mattituck, NY47 homes for saleMedian$912,500−22.3%Days on market119Per sq ft$340
New Suffolk, NY3 homes for saleMedian$979,000Days on market5
Orient, NY16 homes for saleMedian$1,122,500Days on market111Per sq ft$312
Peconic, NY12 homes for saleMedian$1,056,250Days on market12Per sq ft$293
Sag Harbor, NY32 homes for saleMedian$1,999,499Days on market157Per sq ft$1,045
Sagaponack, NY5 homes for saleMedian$7,975,000Days on market63Per sq ft$433
Shelter Island, NY24 homes for saleMedian$1,069,500−57.2%Days on market135Per sq ft$611
Southampton, NY88 homes for saleMedian$3,007,500+147.3%Days on market264Per sq ft$794
Southold, NY77 homes for saleMedian$1,477,500+31.0%Days on market131Per sq ft$389
Springs, NY4 homes for saleMedian$1,133,750Days on market155Per sq ft$346
Wainscott, NY10 homes for saleMedian$1,995,000Days on market179Per sq ft$1,108
Water Mill, NY26 homes for saleMedian$4,100,000Days on market83Per sq ft$943
20